Chinese Authorities Order Bars Not to Serve Black People
Received this from Lord Phat, our resident Chinese linguist and MIT Sloan School of Management graduate that has lived and worked in China:"I originally got this from the webmaster of Afroshanghai.com. It is from the South China Post, a reputable Hong Kong based newspaper. The webmaster is asking the Africans living in Beijing to confirm this and if it is completely true it is very disturbing." Read below. "Authorities order bars not to serve black people" reported 18 July 2008 in the South China Morning Post byTom MillerIn our series looking at preparations for the Games, Tom Miller reports on plans to crack down on "undesirables" in the bars of BeijingBeijing authorities are secretly planning to ban black people and others it considers social undesirables from entering the city's bars during the Olympic Games, a move that would contradict the official slogan, "One World, One Dream".Bar owners near the Workers' Stadium in central Beijing say they have been forced by Public Security Bureau officials to sign pledges agreeing not to let black people enter their premises."Uniformed Public Security Bureau officers came into the bar recently and told me not to serve black people or Mongolians," said the co-owner of a western-style bar, who asked not to be named.The local authorities have been cracking down on blacks and Mongolians in an attempt to stamp out drug dealing and prostitution ahead of the Games, the proprietors said.A few months ago, police launched a violent sting on black men drinking in the Sanlitun bar district, and a notorious nightclub largely populated by Mongolian prostitutes was also shut down.Security officials are targeting Sanlitun, which Olympic organisers expect to be a key destination for foreign tourists looking for a party during the Games.The pledges that Sanlitun bar owners had been instructed to sign agreed to stop a variety of activities in their establishments, including dancing and serving customers with black skin, they said.They have been allowed to keep copies of all the pledges except those relating to blacks, implying that the authorities are wary of charges of racism."I am appalled," said a black British national who works in Beijing. "I understand that the government is trying to stop certain illegal activities, but I don't think blanket discrimination is going about it the right way."Chinese people are prejudiced, but I would have hoped that the government would set a better example as it debuts on the world stage."Calls to Dongcheng district and Chaoyang district public security bureaus, which oversee the bar districts, went unanswered.The authorities' attempt to keep unwanted behaviour from damaging the squeaky-clean image of the Games is the latest example of heavy-handedness that critics say is killing the party spirit of the Olympics.During the Athens Olympics four years ago, bars and nightclubs were allowed to stay open all night. But venues in Beijing that are not being shut down during the Games will have to close at 2am and maintain tight security."The officials told me to inform my customers that they must at all times carry their passports or ID cards," said one bar owner."Security is important, but Beijing is becoming a fortress, and that's not attractive."Rumours that all bars within 2km of an Olympic venue will need to close remain unconfirmed, with many managers complaining that they still have not been told whether they will be allowed to open or not. Several bars have been raided in the past few weeks as local police step up a campaign of low-level intimidation, according to several witness accounts.Bar and restaurant managers in Sanlitun have been instructed to remove tables from footpaths in a crude attempt to prevent fighting in the streets."The local police told us to get rid of the tables because they're scared that if too many foreigners congregate outside there could be trouble," said Song Xun , who runs a burrito joint in the area.Local musicians say that a clampdown on live music risks stifling Beijing's thriving cultural scene and giving Olympic tourists the false impression that the city is artistically anaemic.Several popular live music venues have been shut or instructed to stop all outdoor shows, and club owners complain they have got used to strange new guests nursing a beer for hours and suspiciously observing everything around them."The whole music scene is angry and bewildered. It is impossible to understand how keeping tourists from seeing an open, culturally vibrant and diverse Beijing is possibly a good thing for anyone," said one well-known figure in the local music industry.David Mitchell, a Beijing-based jazz musician, said it had become increasingly difficult for his band to find anywhere to play."It appears the local government is trying to control every aspect of the experience that foreigners get when they come here," he said."Everything is aimed at creating stability, but they don't understand that is precisely the unfounded prejudice that foreigners have of Chinese society - that it is a highly controlled and not a very cultural place. It seems completely self-defeating."Additional reporting by Peter Simpson-------------------------------------------Here is a report that the Chinese government denies the ban:
Beijing, China (AHN) -- Reports have surfaced that the Chinese Government is forcing bar owners to ban blacks and Mongolians from their bars during the Olympic games next month.The pledges are said to be secret, but The South China Daily reported that some bar owners, especially those in Sanlitun, an area known for its nightlife, said they were forced by Public Security Bureau officials to sign pledges agreeing not to allow black people into their bars. Mongolians are also reportedly banned.Some police and bar owners deny this ban is in place, but some Africans reported being charged double what other's pay as entry fees, and others recently told the World Net Daily that they were forced to show their passports prior to being allowed into a bar. No one else had to show such identification. The South China Daily quoted one bar owner as saying police came to him and made him agree, "not to serve black people or Mongolians."It is reported that Chinese officials regard blacks and Mongolians as largely responsible for drug dealing and other criminal activity, and this ban is another measure to control what the rest of the world sees when all eyes are on Beijing for 17 days during the summer games.On the Chinese website Danwei it was written that these bans are highly unlikely, however, unless they were done by low-level police officers. LINK----------------------------Zurui's comment:Could something be lost in translation? Does the "black" refer to "bad elements" and not skin color?The Chinese term for organized crime syndicates or the triads is literally black society.---------------------------------------Lord Phat's comment to a reader that questioned the validity of this story:
- There have been a disturbing upticks of sometimes wanton violence and surveillance by authorities against Blacks in Beijing (where I lived at one time) over the last year. Granted there are Nigerians and Liberians dealing drugs in Sanlitun (mostly to non-Black customers I would add) but there has been at least one incidence, last September, when they came in using physical force to pretty much dislodge every Black male in sight including a diplomat's son. Also, leading up to the Games there has been a massive effort to use visa issues, valid mostly but sometimes questionable, against Africans in different parts of the country to force them out. Afroshanghai is usually good about its sources and wouldn't post crap unless there is valid concern.
- Given your rebuttal blog, there are at least two possibilities:
- The reporter is wrong/mislead/lying and the story is false. Case closed
- The bartenders now claiming ignorance were coerced into silence. This is a far from uncommon practice. If a local bureaucrat had made up this rule and then the higher ups found it embarrassing after international exposure, I would not be surprised if a little pressure was imposed to clear up the evidence.
The blogger you linked brought up valid points though in the politically charged climate, it can be difficult to tell you who is lying and who isn't.The South China Morning Post is not a tabloid. Sometimes HK papers are the only ones that can report dirt on the mainland the mainland papers are unwilling to cover. I also checked out the last six months of articles by the reporter and they were on mostly mundane but factual topics so he isn't a serial sensationalist.
